28 October 2016, by Chris Arnott
If you want to write a phone app, and want it to run on multiple platforms, but don’t want to spend large amounts of time maintaining two code bases, then there are several solutions that allow writing one app, and deploying it to several platforms.
These multi-platform apps work by running a mini website on a phone, which is accessed via a web view, which is how the app appears native.
In this post, we’ll discuss several different approaches to writing a multi-platform app, and have a look which situations you should choose each option.
15 September 2015, by David Simons
This blog posts aims to compare how well the two work: we don’t want to fall in to the trap of suggesting that they are competing with each other as they both do different things. However, as two libraries that make front-end development easier through attributes, it’s rare you’ll use both and so you’ll often reach a time on a project where you have to make a decision between two.
Setting the Framework Up
Setting KnockoutJS up is as easy as you’d like it to be – you can pull the source file into your project by downloading it, linking to their CDN or using package management tools such as Bower. It works nicely with all major dependency tools such as RequireJS, or can be included globally in your project. All you need to do to get it working is call ko.applyBindings in one place. It works nicely with all of your code, and can be added at any stage in the project as it plays nicely with other libraries.
AngularJS is a bit more of a tricky beast – building a project around it from the beginning is not much more effort than KnockoutJS. There’s slightly more boilerplate at an early stage to deal with modularisation, but these costs are mostly compensated by not requiring the set-up of, say, RequireJS.
Adding AngularJS to an existing project, however, is significantly harder. Because of the opinionated idioms that come from the use of AngularJS, it’s often hard to make it integrate seamlessly with other code you’ve already written. We’ve used AngularJS with other module loaders, for example, but the cost of maintaining that has been far higher than expected.
Conclusion: On greenfield projects, both libraries perform well. KnockoutJS is easier to add incrementally to an existing project.
A minor point, but if you have to support Internet Explorer, then you may have a harder time with AngularJS that has a small number of outstanding issues on all IE builds; and no support for IE versions 8 and under. KnockoutJS goes all the way back to IE6.
Conclusion: If IE6 or 7 support is important, AngularJS cannot be used.
We have to be careful about comparing raw statistics of two libraries of differing sizes. In terms of Google Search trends, AngularJS is over 12 times as popular, and exponentially rising. Angular is the second most installed bower package, whilst KnockoutJS doesn’t make the top 100. The trends certainly suggest that AngularJS has more staying power.
AngularJS’s modular nature makes it a natural fit for community support as people can add directives, modules and services that can be easily pulled in and integrated with your code. This means that if you’re requirements are common, then you can use a large number of off-the-shelf libraries.
KnockoutJS does allow you to write bespoke additions by creating your own bindings, or extending the knockout object itself in an easy and well-documented manner. Although there are some KnockoutJS libraries to add features such as Pager.js for routing, there are definitely fewer. At least a few times I’ve thought “Surely someone’s done this already” when writing features with KnockoutJS.
Conclusion: AngularJS is much more popular, and has more community libraries.
Ease of Learning
The documentation and online tutorial for KnockoutJS are some of the best I’ve seen. Knockout is so simple and light-weight that when new developers see it, they’ve always taken to it immediately and are able to contribute to development teams very quickly.
AngularJS is a much bigger beast. Their documentation is, necessarily, much more heavyweight and bulky to reflect the larger amount of things that people have to learn. Almost everyone who has worked long enough with AngularJS is now happy with how it works and can contribute speedily, but it often takes longer to reach the same depth of understanding.
Conclusion: KnockoutJS has simplicity and brilliant documentation on its side; the larger AngularJS can’t compete.
KnockoutJS is unopinionated about tests – it’s a much smaller library so we wouldn’t expect anything else. If KnockoutJS is used with some modularisation frameworks (which we always strongly recommend!) then good discipline, such as encapsulating all low-level DOM manipulation, makes unit testing no harder than with any other library.
Conclusion: Both libraries are testable, though AngularJS was written with this very much in mind, making set-up marginally easier and more documented.
So, which is better…?
We’ve found in projects at Softwire uses for both frameworks.
We typically favour KnockoutJS on projects that have less need for the larger, more opinionated AngularJS. This could be because there is less complex interactions between the user and the data; or because the project simply runs for a shorter time. For legacy projects, it allows us to use it minimally only where we need to, preventing a large initial investment of effort. A lot of developers here love KnockoutJS and many use it on their own pet projects because of its light-weight approach.
We have, however, used AngularJS successfully on a number of projects. We’ve found that the ramp-up time is slightly higher, as it takes control of more aspects of the code base. However, if there is sufficient complexity or on a project, or the code base is larger, the initial set-up and learning costs on a project quickly repay itself and it becomes our framework of choice on large projects with potentially complex user interactions.
We are, as we are with all technologies that we use, constantly examining the ecosystem for new and maturing options outside of these! For those interested in seeing more frameworks in action, TodoMVC is a great website that codes the same site using multiple different libraries.
8 September 2015, by David Simons
1 September 2015, by David Simons
In Softwire, we’ve used AngularJS and KnockoutJS on a variety of projects, and have found that this makes web development a lot easier and a lot more pleasant! With this series of blog posts, I’m hoping to share what we’ve found out about these, and other, data-binding libraries along the way by looking at:
- What groups all these libraries together?
- How do these libraries work?
- Which library is the “best” one?